While a six round test is quite limited, it was enough to tell me what I needed to know and I can share my experiences and observations with you here. Here are my observations on Buffalo Bore .38 Smith & Wesson ammunition:
1. I didn't lose any fingers, eyes, or toes. Much has been made of the power of Buffalo Bore ammunition. However, it didn't blow my gun up. Again, prospective purchasers should carefully read about this ammunition and make sure it is safe for their firearm. With the exception of the Enfield and Webley, old hinged frame revolvers should not use this ammunition.
2. I didn't sustain any permanent damage to my firearm. The aging false ivory grip panels on my Smith & Wesson shifted just a little bit during my firing session. They rotated about 1/8 to a 1/4 inch out of a position. To fix the issue, I simply rotated them back into position. At some point, I need to get some period-correct wooden grips for my revolver. Just as some firearms manufacturers advise customers to avoid a steady diet of +P ammunition, I'm not going to feed my antique revolver a steady diet of Buffalo Bore. While I may need better grips, I didn't see any signs of damage on any of the metal parts. I believe that my vintage Smith & Wesson can handle Buffalo Bore ammunition.
3. I hit the target with excellent accuracy. My Buffalo Bore bullets all hit a paper plate sized EZ2C target at a typical self-defense range of about 21 feet. My bullets impacted a little below the bullseye. However, that is likely due to my shooting since I was just gaining familiarity with the revolver and the sight picture. Note: I oriented my EZ2C target horizontally due to the target frame size at the range.
4. Buffalo Bore .38 S&W ammunition generates more recoil that lower power traditional .38 S&W loads. However, the recoil is not excessive. We are talking recoil that is similar to .38 Special recoil not .357 Magnum recoil.
5. In my old revolver, the Buffalo Bore ammunition was a little more difficult to extract. Where I could simply dump my Magtech .38 S&W shells with a flick of the wrist, I needed to authoritatively push the extractor in to get the Buffalo Bore shells out. Again this may be unique to my revolver which does have pre-existng wear marks inside each cylinder.
6. Overall, I am very impressed by my new Buffalo Bore ammunition. I believe that it does provide the extra thump needed for effective self-defense.
I anticipate consuming my remaining supply of Buffalo Bore Ammunition very slowly over the coming years. For me, Buffalo Bore .38 S&W ammunition will be reserved just for self defense in an emergency. If you are looking for a little extra stopping power for your .38 S&W caliber revolver, Buffalo Bore ammunition may be a good choice.